It looks like you are now trying to convince me with these haplogroup numbers that all these Looney descendants are somehow family related as proven by Y-DNA testing.

I do not dispute the fact that the descendants who were tested are related and all these family lines go back to a common ancestor on the Isle of Man, but not necessarily to Maughold Parish. Until you see a lot more Looney males being Y-DNA tested you will not be able to distinguish which family line is which based solely on Y-DNA results. Let's stick with trying to answer the original question.