Sheila, I expect by now you will have read all the past messages I have sent about John Clugston. Margaret Kinvig will most probably be a relation of mine as it was my great grandparents (John & Ann nee Watterson) who adopted John Clugston but apart from what has already been written on this message board I don't know much about him. (actually John had already died when his wife adopted the child) This is the first info I have as to why he ended up living with the Kinvigs which was of interest to me although my grandmother used to mention him but I think he was called Jack as my gran had 2 brothers , John & Herbert ! There were several Margaret Kinvigs so I haven't researched those families. All for now K