Kay - have been searching google for the census, the only way Robina and John Herbert could have been on the same one was between 1896 [his birth] and 1901 [the year he became a Kinvig] do you know the year of the census or the exact website where i can find it?

If not is there any way you can copy the census and paste it onto and email?

The house by the farm makes sense, we weren't sure whether the family lived in the pink house or whether it was just one close by.

Did Robina ever get married? If so who to and what year?
What was the name of Williams wife and what year did they marry?
What was Bessies married name and what year did she get married?

Thanks again for all your help Kay.