Thanks Liz,
Those Williams definitely look interesting!
Edward I can discount as he has the wrong parents to fit in with my lot. I am wondering if my Edward went to sea as I have found a mention of him in the Royal Navy [I've just put a message on to ask if there is any way to find out more info about the Royal Navy in 1861].
I do wonder if William the Railway Porter is my gr x ? uncle? it would be good to find out marriage or death for him but I get lost once I am off the Island. Thanks so much for your help Liz - greatly appreciated and another line to try and follow.
By the way I have 2 lots of Caine's in my family but I haven't seen any connection to yours yet - if I do I'll let you know. One of my lot were from Kirk Michael / Ballaugh and the other from Rhenshent Malew.
Keep looking and thanks again Viv