I am wondering if the identiication of William Caine (who died in Warrensville, Ohio -- near Cleveland -- November 30, 1837 age 32) as the son of John Cain and Elizabeth Cain, christened at Kk Michael May 18, 1786, still holds.

He married, at Kk Michael, February 25, 1806, Christian Caine, whom Donna identified, some years ago, as the daughter of William Caine and Ann Garrett, christianed at Kk Michael, January 9, 1785. She died at Warrensville, July 30, 1858.

Here is the first generation of what I have about William and Christian:

William Cain, son of John and Elizabeth (Cain) Cain, was christened at Kk Michael, May 18, 1786. He died, probably in Warrensville, November 30, 1837, age 52. William married, at Kk Michael, February 25, 1806, Christian Caine, the daughter of William and Ann (Garrett) Caine, christened at Kk Michael, January 9, 1785. She died July 30, 1858, age 74.

Children of Christian Caine and William Cain, christened at Kk Michael:

i. John Cain was christened December 7, 1806, died 1890. He married, at Kk Andreas, June 8, 1848, Eliza Radcliffe. She died 1898. John remained on the Isle of Man, and inherited the family farm, Ballaskyr.

ii. Ann Cain was christened April 3, 1809. Is she the Ann Cain buried at Kk Michael, June 20, 1817?

iii. William Cain was christened October 27, 1811. Died young?

+ iv. Thomas Cain was christened June 24, 1813. He married, at Braddan, June 12, 1838, Margaret Catherine Quiggin.

+ v. Elizabeth “Betsey” Cain was christened July 23, 1815. She is the "Eliza" age 11, who immigrated with her mother in 1827. She married, in Warrensville, January 17, 1836, Havilla M. Curtis. According to Women of the Western Reserve, she returned to the Isle of Man. Havilla and Betsy Curtis moved to Stark County before the 1840 census.
Children of Betsey Cain and Havilla Curtis:
(1) Marilla was born about 1827
(2) George was born about 1834
(3) William was born about 1837
(4) James Franklin Curtis was born in Massillon, Ohio, February 8, 1838, and died in St. Charles, Illinois, February 8, 1934. Buried Union Cemetery. He married Esther _____;
(5) Elizabeth was born about 1846
(6) Helen Curtis was born in 1855, and died in Detroit, August 3, 1868, age 13.

vi. Ann Cain was christened December 7, 1817.

+ vii. William P. Cain was christened March 9, 1821. Married Louisa Loakes (Loukes?). With Abel in 1850 census.

viii. Philip Cain was christened May 25, 1823. He is the Philip age 4, who immigrated with his mother in 1827. Is he the Philip Cain who married Mary Caine?

+ ix. Abel Cain was christened July 14, 1825. He is the Abel, age 2,who immigrated with his mother in 1827. Married, October 16, 1849, Emeline Chase.

William Cain’s immigration has not been located, but Christian and three of her children immigrated on the Ship Hannibal, from Liverpool, arriving in New York September 25, 1827: Christian Cain 40, Eliza 11; Philip 4; Abel 2; Mary Corkill 18 servant. (All are listed as from England.)

1830 U. S. census: Not yet located

+ x. Christian Cain was born in Warrensville, in 1831, and died March 7, 1908, in her 77th year. With Abel in 1850 census. Christian Caine married, in Cuyahoga County, March 24, 1859, Robert Corlett. Last residence Chardon.

1840 Warrensville census Mrs. C. Caine: 1 male 10-15 (Abel 14); 3 males 15-20 (Philip 17, William, 19 ); 1 female 5-10 (Christian 9); 1 female 60-70 (Christian 56)

1850 Warrensville census # 3151 Abel Caine 24 farmer IOM; Emeline 22 Ohio; Elizabeth 1/12 Ohio; Christine Caine 66 IOM; Christine 19 Ohio; Wm P. 29 IOM; George Chase 17(?) Ohio.