Right as always Frances. I havent much gone into the genealogy of Noreen's mother as I am related to one of her half brothers but the info you gave seems to correspond to what I have. Charles Edwin's 2 wives were related (Both wive's mothers were Wattersons) but I cant find what the exact relation is as Emma's family has proven hard to trace. Thanks for everyones input, hadnt realized I had gotten responses as I somehow forgot to click the box for e-mail notifications (duh!) Thanks Again!

erin