[From Atholl Papers - AP X27(2nd)-12]

The Public Advertiser Saturday August 17 1754

Reasons for annexing the Isle of Man to the Crown of Great-Britain.

LONDON.

In 12 Geo. J. c. 28. by an Act then passed, the Lords of the Treasury were empower'd to treat with the Earl of Derby, and his Heirs, for the Purchase of all Right to the Isle of Man. And this Act was founded upon the almost Impossibility of preventing Smuggling from that Island whilst it remained a petty sovereignity in the Hands of a Proprietor.

The late Lord Derby, from some Notion he had formed of being able to leave the Isle of Man by Will, would not treat with the Treasury. The Duke of Athol, the present Proprietor, may possibly be disposed to part with it on good Terms ; especially when it is consider'd, that most Part of his Revenues arise from small Duties and Customs paid in the Island upon prohibited Goods enter'd, and afterwards smuggled upon the Coasts of England, Wales, Ireland, and Scotland: Which, tho' no Method has yet been found out to prevent, in any Degree (not one in an hundred of the Boats or Vessels concern'd in the smuggling Trade being taken at Sea, or seised afterwards) it cannot be supposed that the Legislature will suffer it long to be carried onto such an enormous Heighth ; which now calls loudly for the serious Attention of every Person that wishes well to the Trade and Welfare of these Kingdoms.

The Isle of Man is situate in the Midst of the three Kingdoms, not above 6 or 7 Hours Sail from the nearest Parts of Scotland, Ireland and England. It is the great Storehouse or Magazine for the French, and other Nations, to deposite prodigious Quantities of Wines, Brandies, Coffee, Teas, and other India Goods ; which are carried off in small Boats and Wherries, built for that Purpose. To ascertain the Quantity, the House of Commons may order the Collectors of the noble Proprietor's Customs in the Island to lay before them their Books of Entries, for the last seven Years, of Goods ; 999 Parts of which, out of 1000, are smuggled upon our Coasts. Upon such an Examination of these Officers the whole Scene would come out.

Of late Years, a new and destructive Trade has been set up by some Irish Papists, who have cheated their Creditors, and carried their Effects to the Isle of Man ; and that is, by importing such Quantities of Teas and other India Goods, as ought greatly to alarm the India Company. Perhaps they do not know to what a Heighth it is come ; or else it is hardly possible they should sit still, and not complain of whole Ship-Loads of Teas, and other India Goods, brought in for some Years past from Denmark, as well as Holland and France; and all smuggled upon our Coasts. The Captain of a Cruiser, a few Years ago, did venture to do his Duty, and at- tempted (as he was warranted to do by an Act of Parliament) to seise a Dutch Dogger, valued at 2000 l. Sterl. which ran from him ashore upon the Island, where she was bound. But the Man found himself mistaken, Acts of Parliament, and an English Commission, could not protect him in that petty Principality. They seised his Men, who had taken Possession of the Dogger; and threw them into Gaol, where five of them lay long. The Captain himself narrowly escaped, with two Men and a Boy, to Whitehaven ; from Which Place he wrote his Complaints to the Commissoners of the Customs. If these Gentlemen were called upon by the House of Commons, not only for these Papers, but also for such Informations as they have received, for some Years past, from the Collectors of Whitehaven and Leverpool, and their Officers in the Isle of Man, no Doubt could remain of the absolute Necessity of annexing this Island immediately to the Crown of Great Britain.

Another pernicious Practice, carried or by some Irish fugitive Papists settled in the Island (who are countenanced and protected) is this : They enter Tobacco in Rolls from several Ports in Great Britain, for some foreign Parts, receive the Drawback, then Carry it to the Isle of Man, and run it back again from thence to Scotland, England, or Ireland, and Wales. This must always be attended with Perjury, a Crime very little regarded by such Persons, who have first cheated their own Creditors, and then rob the Public. Here the Customs are actually robbed of great Sums of Money.

The Isle of Man is likewise a great Detriment to the British Distillery. Most of the Ships that now go from Leverpool to Guiney, &c. touch there for their Brandies, Wines, and India, and other Goods, &c. not of British Manufacture.

These and many other Inconveniencies and Mischiefs arise from suffering this Island any longer to be, in a Manner, independant of Great-Britain.

The Remedy proposed is, to agree with the present Proprietor to relinquish his Right to the Isle of Man, and, in lieu of it, to grant him, and his Heirs, an Annual Sum out of the Customs of England, for ever. And such an Annuity will be a saving to the Government of some thousands a Year, expended to very little purpose in maintaining Cruisers and Officers, &c. to guard against its illicit and pernicious Trade. And ten Times the Number will never prevent smuggling from that Island. This Article alone cannot be less than 15,000 or 25,000 l. a Year, including in this Estimation the Officers in Ireland, who are there on the same Account ; besides the Loss to the Revenne, upon the most moderate Computation, of at least 200,000 l. a Year ; and the Loss to the fair Trader; and particularly the India Company, which may be as much more.

The late Purchase of the hereditable Jurisdictions in Scotland hath set an excellent Example; which deserves Imitation. And indeed the Reasons for annexing this petty Royalty to the Crown hold stronger than in any of the others. For the Detriment, which the whole Kingdom sustains by the Alienation of it, is much greater than that which arose from all the Royalties and Jurisdictions of Scotland. The Loss to the Nation, and the Gains to the French, are inexpressibly great. And as all the Sums drained from us are employed by them in Time of War, to hire Troops and pay Armies to fight against us, it will be no Exaggeration of the Truth to say, That since the Peace of Utrecht they have drawn more Money from us, by means of their Trade with this small Island, than was sufficient to maintain 30.000 Men, with a Train of Artillery, during the late War in Flanders. Would the French have suffered a like Sovereignty and Jurisdiction to remain on their Coasts so greatly to the Detriment of the Kingdom in general? The Case of the Sovereignty of Belleisle, formerly in Possession of the Family of the famous Duke of that name, plainly shews they would not.

In short this Island may be looked upon as a Fortress in the Hands of our Enemies, draining us of our Specie (for all these Goods are paid for with English Coin) and also continually annoying us in the most feasible Part, our Trade and Commerce. And the whole Question is Whether we ought to dispossess them, or not? A Question that admits of no Dispute, if the public Good and Welfare of our Country are to determine it, Nor can there be any one good Reason assigned, why this Island should have remained long in a manner independent of Great Britain

This article would appear to draw heavily on the Memorial of the Whitehaven Merchants