Dan, thanks for the extra info. I'm still puzzled about Thomas Caine and Esther Garrett. The 1851 census doesn't jibe with Esther b1800 but rather with Esther b 1793 Do William Garrett & Esther Christian. Note first daughter is Elinor Christian Caine.
Anyway, I suppose it will all become clear as we go along. Pehaps someone can check the baptism and marriage records.
Let's keep working on this.
Donna