hello again alan
yes it nearly all adds up with details except for archibald i have philip married elizabeth the children being mary- emily-ann-julia-walter-joseph-john being age one and the last in them cenus and christian age 74 widow but no mention of archibald,julia jane went on to marry john thomas cain and had a daughter catherine elizabeth in 1900 and we think she was my dads mum that she had him out of wedlock and had him in 1921 and he was left in poorhouse im sure you and i have same people but im trying to find out about catherine she was adomestic servant as was julia at age of 17 yrs