The Santan Catherine born to Will Curphey & Ann Skinner is about the only possibility.

Apart from the Catharine born to Will Curphey & Ann Shimmin and christened same place, same time.

William, her father, is recorded as "Farmer" on her marriage certificate.

I think the John Wattleworth visiting the Killips at Gobevolly is likely the same John she married, but why Would he describe himself as "unmarried"? My John's Grandmother was Jane Killip so, if that is he, then he would be visiting family at the time of the 1881 census. Seems likely.

Thanks for your help.

Pam (at present having eliminated some 24 Catherine Curpheys of likely age!)