Another candidate based on a man on the 1901 Canada Census, John Corkill, who gives date of birth as 27 Jan 1869 perhaps it should be 1868? This man was a gold miner. He was Manx born, immigrated to Canada from USA in 1899 with US born wife Ellen and US born son John. Possible baptism:-
Name: John James Corkill
Christening: 7 Feb 1868
Church: Maughold, Isle of Man
Father's Name: Robert Corkill
Mother's Name: Jane Corkill
Address: Parliament Street Ramsey
Father's Occupation: Joiner
Record & image:-
familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:X83W-GYL