Thank Sylvia, I was hoping that Herbert Kinvig & his wife Eleanor (nee Kelly9 had a child before he was killed in the war but now from your info I think the child in the phot must be the dau of John H Kinvig (Clugstone) & his wife Nellie. I checked the photo again & see that my mother had written on the back Mrs. J Kinvig & Nellie 1923. So it was not Herbert's wife. Una had mentioned visitors & I think these were Nellie Kinvig & her daughter Eleanor (Nellie) as my mother also mentioned Nellie visiting but I had always thought it was Herbert's wife !