Thanks for the responses. I have just received a copy of the wedding certificate details which had the witnesses as Thomas Radcliffe, Jane Creer and Hudson Horsley but did not give an employment. However I also received a copy of the babtism of their second son"Charles Benjamin" and the profession is shown as School Master. Anyone have any ideas how I can now take this forward as he does not seem to appear in any of the census records or indeed how to find anything more about him?