Hi Brian
Thanks for the information. I did see Catherine (87) as Mother-In-Law so I assumed she was Catherine's (45) mother, as it shows her as a widow.
I am still confused about James. When I requested a baptism certificate for 1847 they sent me the one for Nov. 21, 1847. I didn't know there was another one. I am assuming he was born in 1847 as on the 1881 census it shows him as 34. But I have noticed many discrepancies in the ages.
Also the James that is 1 on the 1851 census has turned into Clucas, age 11 on the 1861 census; so that is also confusing. What happened to James?

Where did you find the baptism certificate for April 22, 1849?
Thanks again Brian but I am now more confused with two James'.
Bonnie