Letter from Ew Corlett - 1931

This letter is included with the Letter & draft thesis chapters of D. Kermode-Parr but is unrelated to that work - however it indicates that the there were academics studying this key 19th Century Act that laid the basis for subsequent education on the Island.

Riverside Ramsey
I.O.M.
Feb 7th 1931

Dear Mr Cubbon

I am still at it with my thesis & many of the reports of commissions etc. that you have at the Museum I have been able to borrow from the Council of Education - hence my absence on Saturdays.

Perhaps you will be able to help me in two important matters.

1. In the First report of the "Board of Education for the Isle of Man" dated 1873 mention is made to a copy appended of a report made on existing elementary schools by Rev Stowell Gill & John Thos Clucas Esq. I find this report of great importance & on p.21 of the Board's main report mention is made that a copy accompanies the Gill-Clucas report showing all the schools & those receiving Government grants. I would like to know if a copy of this map exists - a possibly only the original & if in your possession I should like your permission to copy it.

2. I find this period about 1872 the key position[?] in my thesis. In 1870 the English Elementary Education Act was passed dividing the country into three main classes (a) London (b) Boroughs (c) Parishes all of which they to levy a rate (this had existed in I.O.M. from 1851) if a Govt grant were desired. Presumeably the I.O.M. came under this last heading as it was still receiving annual Imperial grants amounting to £2200 in 1872 i.e. it did not come from Insular Revenue. What puzzles me is that by passing the 1872 Ely Edn Act the IoM seemingly quite automatically took over the whole cost of education & the grants for 1873 were paid out of Insular Revenue - no mention appears in the Act why this should be & as I say it frankly puzzles me.

Can you account for it or refer me to some part of the Constitutions that made this necessary. I realise that in 1866 the Constitution was changed & that after the expenses of Government were paid Tynwald Court had the surplus for public works & development of the Island generally. But why did the Imperial Treasury pay Education Grants up to 1872 from 1866 as previously? My only solution is that prior to 1872 it was regarded as a charge on Insular Revenue reckoned as part of cost of Government & hence leaving that much less as surplus & that after 1872 it was not regarded as a charge on Government & came out of the surplus which wd be greater by that amount

I remain yours sincerely

Ew Corlett.

P.S. With regard to the map I have made enquiries at the Council of Edn Offices & it is not in their possession - also they have enquired at the Rolls Office & Govt Office & they have not the original report or the map. I have just had word to that effect.

Notes

Ew Corlett is presumeably the E.W. Corlett whose unpublished 1931 M.Ed thesis at Manchester is referenced by Hinton Bird.

References

MM MS 2069B includess the thesis chapters and the 1929 letter from Kermode-Parr together with this unconnected letter from another scholar asking about the report arising from the 1872 Education Act.

Hinton Bird An island that led vol 2 Manx National Heritage 1995


School's Index

   

Any comments, errors or omissions gratefully received The Editor
© F.Coakley , 2025