[draft of Chapter 2 of a proposed thesis by Douglas Kermode Parr]
Various Manx historians have given currency to a belief that there were no schools in the Island before the middle of the seventeenth century and that the system of parochial elementary schools was first established by Bishop Barrow, There is, however, sufficient evidence to demonstrate that there were a number of schools at a considerably earlier date,
It would have been strange if there had not been. In England parish schools were to be found as early as the twelfth century.(1) these were available at first for "fairly solid people" only, as the children of serfs were definitely excluded up to the fourteenth century. These restrictions were relaxed early in the fifteenth century and from that time where the parish schools existed, they were open to children who might be sent to them, (2) In Scotland too, parish schools were known in the twelfth century;(3) and towards the end of the fifteenth century there were schools at least in every considerable town. A Scottish Act of 1496 even went so far as to make it compulsory for all burgesses to send their eldest sons to school. (4)
These parish schools were, of course, provided by the Church for the most part, and to ensure that all teaching should be in accordince with the accented theological scheme, the Church made sure of its control by insisting that no one should presume to teach without due ecclesiastical license. (5) It may be said, indeed, that in Elizabethan times attention was directed mainly to the matter of conformity and the licensing of teachers. The same care for orthodoxy led to the prescription of a uniform catechism, which is as much es to say a uniform curriculun, for the catechism was the foundation of all elementary education. (6)
By the beginning of the seventeenth century it was clearly the policy of the English Church that elementary teaching should be universally provided and that it should continue to be exclusively controlled by the ecclesiastical suthorities. In this matter, Church and State were one. It was laid down by statute in 1603 that all schoolmasters should have license from a bishop as a condition precedent to teaching. The duty of providing such teaching was recognised by the canon (1xxviii) of 1604, which provided that in any parish where there was no public school foundation and where there was a curate "which, as a Master of Arts, or Bachelor of Arts, or is otherwise well able to teach youth, and will willingly so do, for the better increase of his living, and training up of children in principles of true religion, we will and ordain that a license to teach youth of the parish where he serveth, be granted to none by the ordinery of that place, but only to the said curate,"(7)
Naturally the provision of these parish schools in Ireland was accomplished only by slow degrees. In the "Gloucestershire Desire", Harmar complained in 1642 of the want of proper miintenance for teachers and the lack of parish schools. (8) In Scotland, also, there were evidently gaps, for the measure of the Estates in 1646, ordering that every parish should provide a schoolhouse and pay a schoolmaster, was later found not to have effected its purpose. (9)
In short, both in England and in Scotland, there were some parish schools at least as early as the twelfth century; their number increased slowly; and in the seventeenth century determined efforts were made to increase the provision, the ideal being a school for every parish.
There is no reason to doubt that the origin and growth of the parish school system would be similar in the Isle of Mann. There were, however, factors which may well have delayed the development of that system. Until 1266 A.D, the Island was under the rule of Norway. There followed a troubled half-century of alternating Scottish and English control. terminated finally in 1405 by the accession of Sir John Stanley, in whose family the sovereign power was to reside for the next three hundred years. Through all this disturbed period the See of Sodor and Mann remained in connexion with Drontheim and it was not till 1458 that, by a bull of Pope Celixtus IV, it was transferred to York. (10) Moreover, the Manx Church during the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries (11) was almost entirely in the hands of the monks, who were not likely to provide in these parishes the education which they could not offer in their monastery. Both civil and ecclesiastical conditions therefore were against any development of elementary education before the fifteenth eentury.
On the other hand, early in the fifteenth century there was a considerable movement of reform in the Church in Mann, many abuses being corrected and various improvements being effected.(12) It is interesting to note that just at the time when the ruling power in England was most adverse to the spread of Lollard principles, the Isle of Man passed into the hands of rulers who strongly favoured them. From the end of the fifteenth century events in the Manx diocese may be said to follow in the wake of the English church, though usually at an interval of forty or fifty years.
In education alone the progress was later to proceed faster than in the greater country; by the middle of the seventeenth century the provision of schools and the episcopal attitude to them certainly approximated to English conditions,
In the absence of documentary evidence, it is impossible to fix even an approximate date for the original establishment of the Manx parish schools, but the balance of probabilities seems to indicate the late fifteenth or early sixteenth century.
The earliest evidence of the existance of schools, or rather of schoolmasters, in the Isle of Mann is to be found in two of the oldest documents preserved in the Manx Museum. In the "Ingates and Outgates" of Castle Rushen for the year 1578, one Peter ffarrand, schoolmaster, is set down for a salary of "iiij li" per annum, having also an allowance for his "dyet and lodging. (13) In a similar account-book of Castle Peele under the date of 1599, there is recorded a payment: "Sallary of the Schoolm/r xx s." (14)
An early eighteenth-century manuscript, certified by the Episcopal Registrar as a correct copy of the original, reproduces a receipt dated 1610, in which "John Lece, Schoolmaster" acknowledges on behalf of John Cosnahan, Minister, a sum paid for repairs executed in Castletown Chapel, (15)
If the payment of schoolmasters may legitimately be held to imply the existence of schools, it is clear that there must have been schools in at least two places in the Island before the close of the sixteenth century.
A few years ago the Manx Museum came into possession of a mass of diocesan papers, Among the unexpected treasures brought to light in exploring the bundles is a portion of the original record of Bishop Foster's Visitation of the parish churches of the Island in 1634, One of the long list of questions asks:"Do any scholm/r keep schole without license?" The replies from several parishes survive in the manuscript, At Kirk Arbory the answer stated simply that there was no schoolmaster without a license. In the parish of Kirk Christ, Rushen, the wardens wrote "our children are cathechised in their mother tongue as may appear and read in due tyme," At Kirk the Vicar catechized the children himself and there was no one "that keeps scoole withot lycense." At Kirk Malew: "Also we declare y/t there is noe schoole kept in o/r p/ish but one, y/e m/r whereof saies he hath his license." From Kirk Onchan came a comlaint voicing a perennial disparagement of a younger generation by an elder; for after answering the actual Question with: "As for Schoolemaster we have none ...", the reply continues:".., but some tymes yong folke when they meett at a weddinge doth use tow much dancinge."! (16)
In his brief tenure of the see, Bishop Foster apparently paid only one visit to the Island, on the occasion of which this enquiry was made, The form of the question, concerning itself solely with the due licensing of the schoolmasters and not with the provision of schools, is neutral in an English churchman of his day. Conformity was of greater importance than education. It may be noted that neither then nor for a century afterwards was there any need of Acts of Uniformity or other special measures to enforce the desires of the Church. In the Isle of Mann the Church retained most of her mediaeval rights; in morals and many of the details of everyday conduct she possessed still the right to issue orders and to call on the civil power for any help needed to enforce obedience, Not till the middle of the eighteenth century was she to lose again in this small community the battle that had long ago been lost on the greater field by Becket
Though chance has preserved so few of the answers to this particular question in Bishop Foster's Visitation, they are fortunately illuminating, It is evident that the idea of schools kept by licensed schoolmasters was familiar, witness the matter-of-fact replies to the effect that there are no unlicensed masters, or that the only master is licensed, It is no very bold conjecture to suppose that the English system was in working order in a number of parishes. Further, it appears that in some parishes the incumbent himself undertook the teaching of the childrens; this was later to become a very important part of Manx arrangements. In the five parishes, rather less thin a third of the diocese, three were definitely without a schoolmaster, and only one categorically stated the existence of a master The parishes are a fairly representative selection of the whole. It is not unlikely, therefore, that at that time those parishes which included a town were provided with a schoolmaster; that in some of the purely rural parishes the vicar kept school; and that a number were still without any means of elementary education
(1) A.F.Leech: Schools of Mediaeval England passim
(2) ibid p 208; 236
(3) J. Edgar History of Early Scottish Education p.90
(4) J Grant History of the Burgh Schools p. 26
(5) A.F.Leech: Schools of Mediaeval England p. 182
(6) F Adams: The Elementary School Contest in England p. 22
(7) J.E.G Montmorency : The Progress of Education in England pp. 44.45.
(8) W.C. Hazlitt Schools School-books and Schoolmasters p.193
(9) J.E.G Montmorency : State Intervention in English Education pp. 120,122
(10) A.W. Moore: Sodor and Man.
p. 89.
(11) ibid. Chap III
(12) ibid. Chap IV
(13) Manx Mus MS
(14) Manx Mus MS
(15) Manx Mus MS
(16) Manx Mus MS; and W. Cubbon: Early
Schools p.117
|
|
||
|
School's Index |
||
|
|
||
|
Any comments, errors or omissions gratefully received
The Editor |
||