Hi Laurence

Thanks for yr reply. My relative can't confirm that Judith Maxwell had Edith as one of her names but says that the parents of Judith Maxwell were James Maxwell and Esther Cleator. The name Esther appears in later generations but not Edith as far as I'm aware.

I have a photo of William Maxwell Turner, the son of Frances Coole (FC was the sister of Anna Maria Coole). Also a photo of Judith Maxwell and James Coole, and one of Anna Maria Coole when she was in her sixties or more. But I don't suppose you'd be interested - these people aren't closely related to yr family tree. Do you have any of the Kneales?
If I find out about 'Edith' I'll let you know.

Thanks again for yr help,
Lorna