Thank you so much for the information. I believe that it is most likely the 2nd one you listed (Robert Starkey and Ann Corlett) because of the birth year. The 1880 U.S. Census lists his age as 52 so that places his birth year within one year of 1828. Is there any other information about the parents listed in the census? I would be very interested in anything that it might contain such as age, occupation, place of birth, other children still living with them, etc.?