Yes, my information was that the other parishes had only (or mainly only) lists of names, as do some of the years in the Andreas ones. I put the Radcliffe confirmations on this message board in 2003 when I first noticed how handy the information could be for bridging the gap in the parish register.
Brian had the index on his website for several years before he died, but it wasn't as useful as it could have been because of omitting the identifying details.

Sue